Quoting sometimes uses the new /post/pid permalinks, and sometimes doesn't.



  • Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Morbi a auctor nulla. Aenean eleifend mauris non augue convallis, non convallis eros porta. Donec hendrerit elit id risus blandit laoreet. Cras rhoncus leo vel sem ultricies vehicula. Nam euismod convallis nulla non bibendum. Aenean posuere eleifend eleifend. Proin mattis ante vel ante sagittis, sed consectetur elit placerat. Cras ornare neque sit amet tincidunt pharetra. Morbi vitae arcu mi. Aliquam pellentesque a odio eget suscipit. Nullam laoreet imperdiet nibh, sed porta velit. Curabitur tempor scelerisque laoreet. Cras eget libero in velit elementum facilisis ac vitae nunc. Class aptent taciti sociosqu ad litora torquent per conubia nostra, per inceptos himenaeos. Ut ac nunc vitae lorem dictum egestas.



  • @anotherusername said in Quoting sometimes uses the new /post/pid, and sometimes doesn't.:

    Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Morbi a auctor nulla. Aenean eleifend mauris non augue convallis, non convallis eros porta. Donec hendrerit elit id risus blandit laoreet. Cras rhoncus leo vel sem ultricies vehicula. Nam euismod convallis nulla non bibendum. Aenean posuere eleifend eleifend. Proin mattis ante vel ante sagittis, sed consectetur elit placerat. Cras ornare neque sit amet tincidunt pharetra. Morbi vitae arcu mi. Aliquam pellentesque a odio eget suscipit. Nullam laoreet imperdiet nibh, sed porta velit. Curabitur tempor scelerisque laoreet. Cras eget libero in velit elementum facilisis ac vitae nunc. Class aptent taciti sociosqu ad litora torquent per conubia nostra, per inceptos himenaeos. Ut ac nunc vitae lorem dictum egestas.

    This is a "Quote". The link is /post/884734.



  • @anotherusername said in Quoting sometimes uses the new /post/pid, and sometimes doesn't.:

    Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Morbi a auctor nulla. Aenean eleifend mauris non augue convallis, non convallis eros porta. Donec hendrerit elit id risus blandit laoreet. Cras rhoncus leo vel sem ultricies vehicula. Nam euismod convallis nulla non bibendum. Aenean posuere eleifend eleifend. Proin mattis ante vel ante sagittis, sed consectetur elit placerat. Cras ornare neque sit amet tincidunt pharetra. Morbi vitae arcu mi. Aliquam pellentesque a odio eget suscipit. Nullam laoreet imperdiet nibh, sed porta velit. Curabitur tempor scelerisque laoreet. Cras eget libero in velit elementum facilisis ac vitae nunc. Class aptent taciti sociosqu ad litora torquent per conubia nostra, per inceptos himenaeos. Ut ac nunc vitae lorem dictum egestas.

    This is a "Reply" with the quoted text highlighted. The link is /post/884734.



  • @anotherusername said in Quoting sometimes uses the new /post/pid, and sometimes doesn't.:

    Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Morbi a auctor nulla. Aenean eleifend mauris non augue convallis, non convallis eros porta. Donec hendrerit elit id risus blandit laoreet. Cras rhoncus leo vel sem ultricies vehicula. Nam euismod convallis nulla non bibendum. Aenean posuere eleifend eleifend. Proin mattis ante vel ante sagittis, sed consectetur elit placerat. Cras ornare neque sit amet tincidunt pharetra. Morbi vitae arcu mi. Aliquam pellentesque a odio eget suscipit. Nullam laoreet imperdiet nibh, sed porta velit. Curabitur tempor scelerisque laoreet. Cras eget libero in velit elementum facilisis ac vitae nunc. Class aptent taciti sociosqu ad litora torquent per conubia nostra, per inceptos himenaeos. Ut ac nunc vitae lorem dictum egestas.

    @anotherusername said in Quoting sometimes uses the new /post/pid, and sometimes doesn't.:

    Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Morbi a auctor nulla. Aenean eleifend mauris non augue convallis, non convallis eros porta. Donec hendrerit elit id risus blandit laoreet. Cras rhoncus leo vel sem ultricies vehicula. Nam euismod convallis nulla non bibendum. Aenean posuere eleifend eleifend. Proin mattis ante vel ante sagittis, sed consectetur elit placerat. Cras ornare neque sit amet tincidunt pharetra. Morbi vitae arcu mi. Aliquam pellentesque a odio eget suscipit. Nullam laoreet imperdiet nibh, sed porta velit. Curabitur tempor scelerisque laoreet. Cras eget libero in velit elementum facilisis ac vitae nunc. Class aptent taciti sociosqu ad litora torquent per conubia nostra, per inceptos himenaeos. Ut ac nunc vitae lorem dictum egestas.

    This is two "Quote"s, pressing the button twice in a row. The first has a link of /post/884734, but the second has a link of /topic/19874/quoting-sometimes-uses-the-new-post-pid-and-sometimes-doesn-t/1.



  • @anotherusername said in Quoting sometimes uses the new /post/pid, and sometimes doesn't.:

    Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit.

    @anotherusername said in Quoting sometimes uses the new /post/pid, and sometimes doesn't.:

    Proin mattis ante vel ante sagittis, sed consectetur elit placerat.

    This is two "Reply"s. The first has a permalink, the second does not.

    @anotherusername said in Quoting sometimes uses the new /post/pid, and sometimes doesn't.:

    Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Morbi a auctor nulla. Aenean eleifend mauris non augue convallis, non convallis eros porta. Donec hendrerit elit id risus blandit laoreet. Cras rhoncus leo vel sem ultricies vehicula. Nam euismod convallis nulla non bibendum. Aenean posuere eleifend eleifend. Proin mattis ante vel ante sagittis, sed consectetur elit placerat. Cras ornare neque sit amet tincidunt pharetra. Morbi vitae arcu mi. Aliquam pellentesque a odio eget suscipit. Nullam laoreet imperdiet nibh, sed porta velit. Curabitur tempor scelerisque laoreet. Cras eget libero in velit elementum facilisis ac vitae nunc. Class aptent taciti sociosqu ad litora torquent per conubia nostra, per inceptos himenaeos. Ut ac nunc vitae lorem dictum egestas.

    And here's another quote. Also not a permalink.



  • tl;dr: the first time you quote something in a reply, you get a permalink; adding more quotes to the same reply results in a non-permalink. It doesn't matter if you clicked "Reply" or "Quote"; the first one gets a permalink and all subsequent ones do not.


  • BINNED

    @anotherusername is it to do with whether you open the reply with a quote or do it when it's already open?

    @anotherusername said in Quoting sometimes uses the new /post/pid, and sometimes doesn't.:

    Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Morbi a auctor nulla. Aenean eleifend mauris non augue convallis, non convallis eros porta. Donec hendrerit elit id risus blandit laoreet. Cras rhoncus leo vel sem ultricies vehicula. Nam euismod convallis nulla non bibendum. Aenean posuere eleifend eleifend. Proin mattis ante vel ante sagittis, sed consectetur elit placerat. Cras ornare neque sit amet tincidunt pharetra. Morbi vitae arcu mi. Aliquam pellentesque a odio eget suscipit. Nullam laoreet imperdiet nibh, sed porta velit. Curabitur tempor scelerisque laoreet. Cras eget libero in velit elementum facilisis ac vitae nunc. Class aptent taciti sociosqu ad litora torquent per conubia nostra, per inceptos himenaeos. Ut ac nunc vitae lorem dictum egestas

    First quote, but I had the composer open. Linking to /topic/19874/quoting-sometimes-uses-the-new-post-pid-and-sometimes-doesn-t/1



  • @Jaloopa Good find.

    Okay, so if a composer has already been opened and you quote something, the link isn't a permalink. (Including when you've used the red boob to hide the composer.)

    If you "Discard" the post you're working on, then quoting something creates a new composer and you get a permalink.




  • sockdevs

    @ben_lubar I can tell you right now what the cause is.

    There's two options for generating a link when hitting Quote, depending on if you have a reply open already or not, and the only one where the link generation was changed was when you start a new reply.

    The other option is just a few lines further down in the same file. Really, the fact that it was missed is, to be frank, shit.



  • @RaceProUK said in Quoting sometimes uses the new /post/pid permalinks, and sometimes doesn't.:

    Really, the fact that it was missed is, to be frank, shit.

    I'm much less surprised by it being missed since the notifications fiasco.


Log in to reply
 

Looks like your connection to What the Daily WTF? was lost, please wait while we try to reconnect.