Bug: Abandoning a reply to user post and replying to a different topic still posts to the original topic
-
Continuing the discussion from Bug: Sending PM that crashes preview pane is preserved - crashing profile page:
Knowing these forums, somebody probably figured out a way to persist a logout bomb that checks if the user is Nagesh.
I was playing with my crash code and decided I wanted to reply on another thread, so i clicked 'cancel reply' -> 'yes, abandon' and clicked reply to user (the same user who I was originally replying to @codinghorror) and my reply went to the wrong topic.
-
Not clear, what is the step by step repro here exactly? You can also test on try.discourse.org sandbox if you like.
-
This post is deleted!
-
- Open a topic, click 'reply' to a specific user post (untested with first post)
- Start a reply
- Change your mind, go to some other topic
3a) Click 'Cancel' to cancel the reply from the other topic - Click 'reply' to a specific user in the other post (in my case, I used @codinghorror in the original post, and @codinghorror in the second post)
- Post
- Have content post to wrong topic
Note: No popup prompted if I wanted to post in the new topic location, or old topic location. So it might have been an issue with that logic.
-
No repro. Here's what I did.
- Opened this topic, clicked Reply to you (Matches) on the above post
- Started a reply
- Visited another topic by going to your profile
- Clicked "cancel" to cancel my in-progress reply on that other topic
- Clicked "reply" on a post you made in the other topic
- Posted
- Reply was posted on the expected topic:
http://what.thedailywtf.com/t/the-official-hack-testing-thread/1081/16?u=codinghorror
No repro for me. Can you repro this on try.discourse.org because I can't repro it.
-
